New Zealand Principal Magazine

Being On the receiving end – When the complaint is about you

Rebecca Laney and Charlotte Coutts · 2026 Term 4 August Issue · Practice

PASL legal team at Anderson Lloyd

PASL Logo

Most principals will deal with complaints at some point in their career. But you are usually the one managing the issue, so what happens when the tables turn and the complaint is about you?

Being told that your Board has received a complaint about you and is considering a formal investigation can be unsettling, particularly when the information initially provided is limited. What is being alleged? What happens next? Do you need a lawyer? PASL supports principals through these processes, often becoming involved, quietly and confidentially, when a principal receives the first letter from their Board and is trying to work out what to do next.

While a full investigation can be expensive, time-consuming, disruptive, and personally difficult for the principal involved, a complaint does not automatically require a formal investigation and the appointment of an external investigator. The Board should first consider what the actual concern is and the most appropriate way to deal with it before starting a formal investigation. Is it misconduct, a performance issue, or something that could be addressed through discussion, coaching, or another process?

What you can expect when a formal process is proposed

When more formal processes are required and an investigation is proposed, it is essential to get advice early. Principals generally want to be cooperative and transparent, and to get things done, but you don’t have to agree immediately to a process before understanding why it has been proposed and what it may involve. “I’ll consider that and come back to you,” is an entirely appropriate first response to your Board, and gives you an opportunity to get advice and support, including from PASL, as early as possible. Remember, early notification of actual or potential issues is a condition of coverage under the PASL legal scheme.

Before any formal investigation can take place, your Board needs to clearly explain what the complaint is, what will be investigated, who will conduct the investigation, what will happen once the investigator reports back, and who will make any employment decision. Importantly, they need to outlay the most serious possible outcome if the allegations are substantiated, which needs to reflect the seriousness of the conduct alleged. For example, if the allegation could only result in a final written warning, the Board should not raise dismissal as a possible outcome. Being told that your employment may be at risk has obvious consequences for a principal and should not be included simply as standard wording.

Why the terms of reference are important

The principal should be provided a Terms of Reference for comment. Pay close attention to this. It sets the boundaries for the investigation, including what is being investigated, who is involved, how the process will operate, and what the investigator has been asked to determine. If the scope is unclear or too broad, it is easier to address that at the beginning than after interviews and evidence-gathering.

It is critical that you have all the information to properly respond to allegations. That may include the complaint, witness accounts, emails, file notes, and any material gathered during the investigation. Information may sometimes be withheld if it is deemed irrelevant, confidential, or unnecessary. There may also be legitimate privacy issues, particularly where staff, students, or whānau are involved, but confidentiality should not prevent a principal from knowing the substance of the case against them or having a fair opportunity to respond to information relied on.

Having the right support during investigations and interviews

Legal or union representation and personal support serve different purposes. Your representative deals with the employment and procedural issues. A support person can help with the practical and personal side of a process that may continue for weeks or months. For principals, a useful support person may be someone experienced in school leadership who can remain calm and objective. You need someone who is there for you, but who is also prepared to tell you (privately and not in front of the Board) when they see something differently. It is essential to choose your support team carefully and take time to prepare.

Investigations, particularly investigation interviews, can be demanding. Even experienced principals can find it hard to recall dates or explain decisions clearly when they are under pressure. Preparation means knowing the chronology, reviewing the relevant documents, and thinking carefully about the decisions you made at the time; it does not mean rehearsing answers. Don’t rush during the interview. Ask for a question to be repeated or for a break if you need one. Answer the question asked. If you cannot remember something, say so — there is nothing wrong with saying, “I don’t recall”. Guessing can create more problems later, particularly if other documents or evidence emerge.

When the report arrives

The investigation report will show how the investigator reached their findings. Each allegation should be addressed separately, with the report identifying the relevant evidence, dealing with conflicting accounts, acknowledging gaps or limitations, and explaining why particular evidence has been preferred. Importantly, the findings should stay within the Terms of Reference. As with the Terms of Reference, the principal should have an opportunity to see the draft and comment on it before it is finalised and provided to the Board. This allows the principal to identify factual errors, respond to any new or adverse material, and comment on the investigator’s reasoning or proposed findings.

The Board cannot simply hand the process to an external investigator and accept the report without scrutiny. It must still consider the evidence, the investigator’s reasoning, and the principal’s response before making any employment decision. The Employment Court’s decision concerning Mr Gumbeze, a senior social work practitioner at Oranga Tamariki, provides a useful example. The Court identified several problems with the investigation and the disciplinary process that followed. These included issues with the Terms of Reference, a failure to adequately investigate relevant information or interview relevant witnesses, and conclusions based on assumptions that had not been properly tested. The Court was critical of the employer’s reliance on the investigation report without sufficient scrutiny, showing that an external investigation does not remove an employer’s responsibility to act fairly.

Don’t navigate it alone

Principals are accustomed to being the person others turn to when something goes wrong. Being the person whose conduct is under scrutiny is very different. Principals sometimes contact PASL only after the process is already well underway, when Terms of Reference may have been agreed, interviews arranged, and decisions made about what information will be provided. This can sometimes unfairly affect the outcome and, in some cases, your employment.

Getting advice does not mean taking an adversarial approach. You can engage constructively with your Board while still making sure the process is fair and that you are properly supported. Getting advice early helps you understand the process before you are in the middle of it. If there are concerns, it allows you to put them on the record constructively. It also gives you someone who can look at the situation from the outside, identify issues you may not have considered, and help you prepare for what comes next.


For PASL membership support, please contact the Privacy Officer, Jacquie Kenton on jacquie@pasl.nz or 021 385 014.
The Legal Hotline for PASL members can be contacted on 03 477 3973.

New Zealand Principal Magazine: Term 4 2026