Towards the end of an exceptionally turbulent schooling policy year, I thought we might take some time to reflect on the main object of all our professional endeavours, energies, and commitments: mokopuna, children, and young people.
We have heard a lot during the last three years about what parents are claimed to want from their children’s schooling, about what is allegedly missing from tumuaki and principals’ leadership of learning toolkit, and about what ministers believe will most likely secure children’s academic achievement and preparedness for the paid work economy. Yet, through all that, we have heard precious little about what children themselves are hoping for as a result of being compelled to spend more than twelve thousand hours in increasingly scripted and routinised classrooms and schools.
The voices of children and young people are all but absent from the processes of curriculum, assessment, and teaching policy reform today. This is ironic not least because, as all tumuaki and principals know, children cannot be forced to learn. As highly skilled professional educators, we can only create the conditions in which children see themselves as successful learners who want to engage and achieve. We therefore need to see them and, more importantly, for them to see themselves as capable learners who are intently curious about — and deeply immersed in — their natural, social, creative, and spiritual worlds.
In this sense, we need to help them develop their “internal capabilities”, as the American philosopher Martha Nussbaum describes. Capabilities are the “trained or developed traits and abilities” necessary for functioning in society. In compulsory schooling, we might reasonably observe that most schools and kura in Aotearoa New Zealand do a good enough job in developing children and young people’s internal capabilities. However, it’s an open question as to whether we do enough for all mokopuna to provide “the avenues through which people actually have the opportunity to function in accordance with those capabilities”. For Nussbaum, then, capability implies both freedom and opportunities “for choice and action” in one’s individual situation. A major implication for compulsory schooling is that the learned curriculum (as opposed to the official curriculum) needs to scaffold children and young people’s freedom and opportunities for self-determined choice and action.
Nussbaum’s human development approach to capabilities may appear a little too abstract for our purposes, so let me be clear that I am not encouraging tumuaki and principals to take on anything like the radically progressive mantle of A. S. Neill.
Neill was the founder of what was once the world renowned ‘experimental’ Summerhill School. He described it as a place “where children are reared in happiness”. At Summerhill, all decisions were taken democratically: “Each member of the teaching staff and each child, regardless of his [sic] age, has one vote. My vote carries the same weight as that of a seven-year old.” I am, though, asking you to reflect on the implications of Elwyn Richardson’s account of his learning as principal at Oruaiti school in the Far North in the mid-twentieth century for your own leadership of learning work. In the briefest of Introductions to In the Early World, he writes, “For what I myself learned during these years I have mainly my children to thank. They were my teachers and I was theirs, and the basis of our relationship was sincerity.”
In 1993, the New Zealand government ratified the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNRCR). Since then, we have also ratified the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD) in 2008; and supported but not ratified the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) in 2010, having initially voted against it in 2007. Ratification of a UN Convention means that: we have consented to be bound by it; to implement it in our laws, policies, and state institutional practices, including schooling; and to report periodically on our progress to the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child.
Two of the fifty four articles in the Convention are particularly relevant to children’s freedom and opportunity. Article 12 (in part) says:
States Parties shall assure to the child who is capable of forming his or her own views the right to express those views freely in all matters affecting the child, the views of the child being given due weight in accordance with the age and maturity of the child.
Article 29 (in part) says that the education of the child shall be directed to, “the development of the child’s personality, talents, and mental and physical abilities to their fullest potential.”
To my knowledge, mokopuna have not been consulted nationally on our current wave of schooling reforms. Equally, I have read no reports of children and young people being given opportunity to express their views on these curriculum, assessment, and teaching matters that are clearly of interest to them, and their practical implications for classroom and school life.
In an era when we read a lot about the importance of ‘student voice’ in schooling, this is deeply disappointing to me. It suggests that many politicians and educators are unaware of the rights of the child or that they believe that children are not mature enough to express views on their schooling — that the child’s right to do so should be carefully controlled and circumscribed. What does this tell children about the kind of civil society they are being prepared for through schooling? What about the opportunities to do and to be in that society that they will eventually have to choose? And, moreover, what chance do we have of developing the child to their fullest potential if we do not enable and support them to frame and take meaningful decisions about their learning at school?
In her influential 2007 paper, Professor Laura Lundy argued that “voice is not enough” to fulfil states’ and state institutions’ obligations under UNCRC Article 12. Rather, children need space, voice, audience, and influence. Space that is built into the fabric of classroom and school life; a genuine, not confected, voicing of their views on matters of interest to them; an audience of adults that actively listens to their views; and tangible influence for mokopuna in decisions that affect them, together with respectful feedback when it is decided that their views cannot be acted on. If we add to this the idea that children’s voice is embodied through the multisensory and spiritual ways in which children experience schooling, individually and collectively, it ought to be apparent to tumuaki and principals that we have a long learning journey ahead before we can say that, as educators, we give full effect to UNCRC Article 12.
Approaching the end of the 2010s, the situation was markedly different. The School Trustees Association and Office of the Children’s Commissioner conducted a national children’s voice survey. This resulted in a sobering series of reports on the gap between children’s aspirations for schooling and the reality of what they experience on a daily basis (Education Matters to Me, 2018). Relatedly, whenever a major education policy proposal landed on his desk, former Minister of Education Chris Hipkins is said to have asked officials, “Has this been seen by my Ministerial Youth Advisory group?” and to decline to read papers until the advisory group had the opportunity to comment.
The Tomorrow’s Schools Taskforce argued in 2019 that the cornerstones of the future schooling system must be Te Tiriti o Waitangi and the rights of the child (as articulated in UNCRC, UNCRPD, and UNDRIP). One of the Taskforce’s recommendations was that the Office of the Children’s Commissioner (OCC) should review children’s participation in school governance on the grounds that one student representative on secondary school boards was inadequate in a future rights-based schooling system. The Commission’s subsequent review recommended developing a much more ambitious mechanism for student engagement in governance and management decision making. Instead, the Ministry of Education’s Briefing Note in 2021 to Minister Hipkins on the OCC review recommended that it work with the Commission to develop guidelines to support a legislated mechanism for student engagement in decision making, but expressed concern that the Commission had conflated governance and management.
The Covid-19 pandemic unfortunately meant that any attention to children’s engagement in schooling decision making morphed into simple improvements in attendance and achievement. That ‘democratising moment’ appears to have been lost. And this, despite the fact that back in 2003 then Education Minister Trevor Mallard commended the findings of an ERO national report which “indicated that key strengths in our schools are the involvement of students in decision making at an organisational level through student representative mechanisms, and also the involvement of students at the classroom level in decision making.” According to Minister Mallard, ERO had found that “effective student participation in school decision making contributed to: better student motivation, learning, confidence, and self-esteem; better school processes, including more successful implementation of school initiatives, and improvements in student behaviour; and better relationships between students, teachers, parents, whānau, and community.” Nevertheless, he noted that schools needed to improve their processes so that all students participated “regardless of ethnicity, sexual identity, disability, religious belief, and gender”.
I leave you to ponder the principal’s role today in giving practical effect to UNCRC Article 12 in their school’s governance and management, and encourage you to think about how you can better enable student participation decision making within your classrooms and your schools.