Professional Insight
Principals – have you ever posed this question to your staff? Do you accept that invite to an 18th birthday party? Do you answer that late night text from a student who says they are feeling depressed? These are just some of the issues teachers must navigate throughout their career. Maintaining professional boundaries is a critical skill for any teacher. Determining where the boundary lies is not always straight forward and often presents as an ethical issue for teachers. Having a clear sense of what is acceptable conduct for a teacher and some idea about what to do when you find yourself in a ‘grey area’ is vital for the safety of the teacher and the student/s. The Code of Professional Responsibility sets out the standards for ethical behaviour that are expected of all teachers. This article focuses on commitment to learners, specifically clause 2.2 – engaging in ethical and professional relationships with learners that respect professional boundaries. The Code applies across all sectors of the teaching community (early childhood, primary and secondary). Our Code: Examples in Practice provides teachers with an excellent guide as to what complying with the Code might look like. It also provides examples of behaviour that may not comply with the Code. Boundar y breaches can be emotional, financial, c om mu n i c at i on , or s e x u a l breaches. Grooming is at the more serious end of a boundary breach as it can amount to a criminal offence. Grooming is deliberate and calculated with the groomer’s goal being to create a strong, emotional connection with a child or young person as a way of gaining that child’s trust prior to initiating a sexual relationship. Being aware of the signs of grooming is very important as a teacher. There are areas where there is an increased risk of a boundary breach. Teachers who become a confidant, friend or counsellor to the student/s are on a slippery slope and can, quite unintentionally cross the line. Being a confidant is particularly dangerous if the teachers themselves are vulnerable or having a difficult time in their personal lives. Those teachers may appreciate the adoration and emotional dependence they have created as they seek to get their own needs met. But undoubtedly this can affect student
well-being and learning. Physical environments may also be a factor. Older style classrooms may have fewer or higher windows and teachers in these environments should take extra steps to ensure everyone’s safety (both teacher and student/s) – consider leaving doors open and avoid being in classrooms with only one student. Modern learning environments in primary school settings provide greater visibility and co-teaching provides teachers with another adult in the same space which can be helpful. Some teachers, new to the profession, may not have developed a strong sense of professional identity. In the secondary school setting, they may only be a few years older than their students and if they live rurally, may socialise with them. These beginning teachers need support from their senior teachers to understand what is and isn’t acceptable behaviour as a professional. However, some teachers just get carried away, enjoy the attention given to them by their students and behave unprofessionally. Here is an example: ‘Teacher L ’1 taught ‘Student E’2 when she was in Year 12 and 13. On Student E’s last day of school (Dec 2016) she texted Teacher L to thank him for his input into her academic and sporting achievements. She also said she would like to bring him a cake the next day. She brought in the cake to school, and they had a conversation about her future plans which lasted about 45 mins. Teacher L then emailed Student E to thank her for the cake. Emails between the two of them went back and forth until January when Teacher L set up a private ‘Chatstep’ online ‘chat’. They chatted over January often late at night or in the early morning. Teacher L asked intimate questions like: ‘what are you wearing?’, ‘how many times [have you] had sex?’ etc. Teacher L was 49 and an experienced teacher. Student E was 18. In February 2017 Teacher L set up a Facebook account
Boundaries
with the purpose of continuing the ‘chat’ with Student E. He used a pseudonym to avoid his wife finding the page and so he could save the conversations (as Chatstep automatically deleted the chat). In May 2017, Student E thanked Teacher L for helping her with her university studies and asked Teacher L to stop messaging her as she felt the conversation was inappropriate. In June the school became aware of the messages and began an investigation. In July the school submitted a mandatory report to the then Education (now Teaching) Council. Teacher L told the Disciplinary Tribunal that his own family had been profoundly affected by his conduct. The Tribunal was not assured that Teacher L would not engage in further similar conduct as he had done no reflection or taken any remedial steps. Teacher L’s registration was cancelled. Teacher L was granted name suppression to protect the identity of Student E and his own son.’ This case illustrates the damage that can be done by a boundary breach. Not only does it affect the student involved. It affects the teacher, their career, their families, and community. It also lowers the reputation of teaching profession. Parents need to be assured that teachers won’t take advantage of their children. It is widely accepted (especially during a pandemic) that using online platforms is an essential way for teachers to communicate with their students. School online learning platforms offer a safe and monitored communication space, but using social media is an area where things can go very off track. All social media platforms encourage a type of communication that is casual and informal, and the use of emojis is common – some of which have ‘alternative’ meanings. Do you know what the eggplant emoji means?
The speed at which the communication occurs on social media is also a risk factor. People expect instant replies. How often have you misinterpreted what another person has written? The chance that a teacher’s ‘friendly’ message could be misinterpreted as ‘flirtatious’ is enormous. Does your school have a policy for the use of social media? There should be a clear distinction between professional and private and any communication with students needs to be solely focused on educational issues. Teachers need to consider that anything they say on social media is permanent and publishable. Despite ‘privacy settings’ anything can be screenshot – and we know how tech-savvy the kids are. Before you hit ‘send’ or ‘post’ ask yourself whether you would be happy if your Principal, your partner or the lawyers at the Teaching Council read it. Teachers should be careful not to encourage a student to develop an emotional dependence on the teacher and avoid treating a student as ‘a friend’. A teacher must set the tone and focus the teacherstudent relationship on learning and wellbeing, not friendship. If a student needs support beyond the learning environment, a teacher should refer the concerns on to appropriate people and agencies. Under the Code of Professional Responsibility, if you are concerned about another teacher, you have a professional duty to take action (Clause 1.5). Reporting a colleague is always going to be a tough call but you need to understand that the well-being of students is paramount, and you have an obligation to protect them from harm. (Code 2.1). There are a number of ways to prevent yourself from crossing a professional boundary. Things aren’t always clear cut. Developing self-awareness and engaging in critical self-reflection is a key tool for any professional, particularly when assessing whether there is a risk of breaching a professional boundary. Being safe and protecting yourself and your profession requires a degree of insight. As a teacher you need to examine your own thoughts, feelings and actions towards your students. If you think
you are at risk of crossing a boundary or have actually crossed one, you need to tell a colleague, your senior or your Principal and discuss it. At all times it is the teacher’s responsibility to maintain the boundary. Professional tensions will be frequently faced and your commitment to uphold the high professional standards of the teaching profession requires self-reflection, openness and transparency. This is all a part of the life-long learning journey that a teacher engages in across their career. Professional Insight offers a half day course for teachers about Professional Boundaries (online or in-person). A course outline is available on request. About us: Bindy Tatham and Rachel Kent have recently been in-house lawyers at the Teaching Council advising investigators (investigating alleged professional misconduct) and Complaints Assessment Committees (who assess the teacher’s conduct). Bindy and Rachel have recently set up an investigations firm and are both licensed Private Investigators and enrolled Barristers and Solicitors of the High Court. Rachel is also a registered social worker. Here is the link to the website: www.professionalinsight.co.nz Rachel: Prior to being a lawyer Rachel was a social worker for 13 years and worked with a number of different groups – children, families, older adults, refugees. Rachel then did a law degree and has mainly worked for
professional regulators (Medical Council, Social Workers Registration Board, Veterinary Council, Real Estate Agents Authority and Teaching Council) in a number of different roles – lawyer, investigator, lay member and Convenor on CACs, and on Performance Assessment Committees (competence assessments for doctors). Rachel was the first lawyer at the Social Workers Registration Board and wrote their Code of Conduct. Rachel then did investigations for the Teaching Council and subsequently was employed as an in-house lawyer. Bindy: Prior to working at the Teaching Council, Bindy did conduct investigations for the Veterinary Council and Social Workers Registration Board and was a report writer at the Teaching Council. In the earlier part of her career, she was a commercial lawyer at Kensington Swan (Wellington) and Anderson Lloyd (Dunedin) before stepping out of the workforce to raise her daughters. We would be very happy if Principals wanted to contact us directly. Our emails are: rachel@professionalinsight.co.nz or bindy@professionalinsight.co.nz Our mobile phone numbers are: Rachel 027 348 1326; Bindy 021 735 153
References 1 Teacher L v CAC NZTDT 2018/23 2 Teacher L and Student E both have name suppression.
Designed and engineered in the UK since 1968
BATTERY POWERED PORTABLE LOUDSPEAKER
The Tensor-GO all-in-one column PA delivers a superior audio experience from an ultra portable system. The integrated high performance Lithium-ion battery enables long system usage with crystal clear audio coverage for 100+ people without the requirement of a mains power supply.
1 CHARGE = LASTS UP TO 20 HOURS
Perfect for live events, P.E. classes, gyms and school camps.
Bluetooth
Two Universal Inputs
Mix Out
To request a demo or for more info contact Ryan on 021 750 273 or e-mail ryan@nsl.co.nz
BLUETOOTH
PROUDLY DISTRIBUTED BY
100+ PEOPLE
BACK Charging Input
Ex
p
ing play experiences to z a m a ring e or more than 30 years f s v d i i k l i e w Ki d n i s e rt Support local with our New Zealand designed and manufactured playgrounds. • Park Supplies & Playgrounds design and manufacture playgrounds right here in New Zealand and have been doing so for more than 30 years. • We customise to your specific needs rather than importing componentry from overseas and you have the reassurance that our equipment is robust and made for New Zealand conditions.
Our playgrounds are designed to meet the needs of your students at your school. • Park Supplies & Playgrounds provide imaginative and fun playground solutions to aid in development, fitness and learning. • We value input from your staff and students and will involve you in the design process to ensure your playground needs and dreams are realised.
Contact Park Supplies & Playgrounds today to begin your new playground journey
09 527 4666
www.parksupplies.co.nz
Melissa Cowie 021 502 220 melissa@ parksupplies.co.nz
Jenny Mullins 021 822 676 jenny@ parksupplies.co.nz
ADVERTORIAL
SchOOL BuDgETIng – STRETchIng ThE DOLLARS Given the challenges posed by COVID-19, Schools and their whānau have proved to be amazingly resilient over recent years; learning to adapt, innovate and enhance learning experiences by quickly implementing online learning platforms. This has changed education forever and driven the need for longer-term strategies and streamlined processes throughout the rest of the school environment. With this in mind, timely and informative budgets play a vital role in providing principals and boards with financial confidence during these uncertain times. A well-constructed budget can also provide opportunities, facilitating instant decision-making when required. Budgets should not just be viewed in the context of the next 12 months but also consider the school’s longer-term strategic goals; what does the board want to achieve in the next 5 to 10 years? This ensures that not only the children of today are benefiting from sound financial decisions but also future generations. Those future generations will also contribute to the community during the years ahead. Given the importance of reliable financial information in order to deliver enhanced resources for students and teachers alike, schools need access to value-adding financial solutions and knowledgeable support. Choosing the right solution and engaging an experienced support provider is critical. When preparing an annual budget, every school is different and, as such, requires personalised assistance. Sound advice should provide suggestions around enhancing revenue and be considered when making some of the tough spending decisions. As part of the onboarding process at Accounting For Schools, we take a lot of time and care to understand a school’s specific requirements and needs. A comprehensive and accurate annual budget for the coming year should also consider the impacts on the years beyond as well. We have developed several cloud-based collaborative tools, including customised budget templates, staffing calculators, and asset replacement programmes. We are genuinely focused on the long-term future of all schools, not just the next few months. A budget is only as good as the information available, however, At Accounting For Schools, we are proud to be a Xero platinum partner,
using the latest technology to provide insight and deliver confidence around the Schools finances. We utilise cloud-based accounting software that can be accessed from anywhere in the world. Xero provides accurate, understandable, and timely financial information. It also gives back control to the school, allowing payments to be made when required, management of categorising expenses, and the ability to collaborate with multiple invested partners. When preparing financial information for schools, such as monthly management reports, we strive to provide understandable summaries of the key impacts and how those impacts are now being managed. Our team of school experts provides timely support, genuine advice, and technical expertise to help schools make more informed decisions. By utilising Xero, Google Drive, and other cloud-based applications, Accounting For Schools can assist and support schools in any part of the country; we also enjoy travelling when we can to meet with schools face to face. These systems also enable collaboration and allow us to deliver a more streamlined process, ensuring faster delivery for schools, which also extends to our annual accounts support process. When it comes to the annual audit and the year-end financial statements, many schools find this a daunting and time-consuming exercise. At Accounting For Schools, we view audits as an excellent opportunity to review the school financials, not just a box-ticking exercise. We seek to filter the audit queries, mitigating needless disruption during an extremely busy time of the year for the school support team and ensuring statutory deadlines are met. Using Xero already? Mention this article, and we will provide access to our budget training toolkit and prepare a budget template for 2023 in Xero for your school at no cost. If your school needs assistance with preparing a multi-year budget or enhanced monthly reporting, please contact Ben Duflou or Allison Henderson today for a no-obligation chat. We will be able to tailor a solution specific for your school’s needs. Accounting For Schools – www.afsl.nz. Ph: 0800-ASK-AFS (0800-275-237)